| Hymnal
| Number
| Lyrics
|
| Hymns Ancient & Modern, 1861-1874
| # 42
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Church Hymnal (US), 1871-1874
| # 19
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymns with Tunes, 1874
| # 85
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymnal (Church of Ireland), 1874
| # 87
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Hymns Ancient & Modern, Standard, 1875-1924
| # 59
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Hymnal Companion, 1890
| # 86
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Church Hymnal, 1892 (Darlington)
| # 49
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Church Hymnal, 1892 (Parker)
| # 49
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Church Hymnal, 1892 (Hutchins)
| # 49
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Church Hymnal, 1892 (Helfenstein)
| # 49
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Church Hymnal, 1892 (Messiter)
| # 49
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymns, New Edition, 1903
| # 92
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Hymns Ancient & Modern, New Edition, 1904
| # 59
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The English Hymnal, 1906
| # 28
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Book of Common Praise (Canada), 1908
| # 72
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Hymnal 1916 (US)
| # 72
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymnal for the Christian Year, 1917
| # 108
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymnal (Ireland), 1919
| # 86
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymnal Revised, 1920 (Hutchins)
| # 48
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Oxford Hymn Book, 1925
| # 69
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Songs of Praise, 1925
| # 52
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Songs of Praise, Enlarged Edition, 1931
| # 78
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Book of Common Praise (Canada), 1938
| # 75
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Hymnal 1940 (US)
| # 12
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Hymns Ancient & Modern, Revised, 1950
| # 59
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Mirfield Mission Hymn Book, 1955
| # 87
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymnal (Ireland), 1960
| # 64
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Anglican Hymn Book, 1965
| # 106
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Hymn Book 1971 (Canada)
| # 415
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Australian Hymn Book, 1977
| # 228
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The Hymnal 1982 (US)
| # 83
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Hymns Ancient & Modern, New Standard, 1983
| # 34,326
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| The New English Hymnal, 1985
| # 30
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Hymns for Today's Church, 1987
| # 65,597
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Hymns Old & New, New Anglican, 1996
| # 357
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Common Praise (Canada), 1998
| # 118
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Together in Song (Australia), 1999
| # 304
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Sing Glory, 1999
| # 357
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Complete Mission Praise, 2000
| # 490
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Common Praise, 2000
| # 61
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Hymns Old & New, Complete Anglican, 2000
| # 479
| O come, all ye faithful
|
| Church Hymnal (Ireland), 2000
| # 172
| O come, all ye faithful
|
